When it comes to the best superhero movies of all time, plenty of stellar films are in the running. Marvel and DC both have massive cinematic universes to consider, and they are both entering exciting new eras.

Ranking superhero films is like choosing your go-to flavor at an ice cream store with a seemingly infinite number of possibilities—difficult, personal, but unquestionably entertaining. Luckily, Rotten Tomatoes has taken some of the weight off it.